By Chris Seiter

Published on June 18th, 2024

Imagine waking up on a Sunday morning, coffee in hand, the sun pouring through your window.

You check your phone, and there it is—a message from your ex-girlfriend, titled “Dear John.” It feels like a punch to the gut. A wave of emotions hits you—shock, confusion, maybe even a little hurt pride.

What do you do now?

In short, when dealing with a Dear John type of letter from your ex, you need to take into consideration that how you respond is largely depending on your circumstance.  Start first with understanding why your ex is sending such a letter, then you can move toward how best to respond and what you should do thereafter.

Let’s unravel this emotional tapestry together, delving into why she might have sent it, what you should say or do, and most importantly, what you should never do.

What Are Your Chances of Getting Your Ex Girlfriend Back?

Take the quiz

Understanding the “Why”

Before diving into your next steps, it’s crucial to understand why she sent this letter. The motivations behind such a message can vary significantly, and recognizing the underlying reasons can help you respond appropriately.

  1. Closure: One of the most common reasons for a “Dear John” letter is closure. She might feel that unresolved issues linger between you two, and this letter is her way of putting a period at the end of your story.
  2. Apology and Forgiveness: Perhaps she’s seeking forgiveness for past mistakes, or maybe she wants to apologize for her own actions. This can be her way of making amends and moving forward with a clean slate.
  3. Rekindling: Sometimes, a “Dear John” letter isn’t about saying goodbye but about re-opening the lines of communication. She might be testing the waters to see if there’s a chance to rekindle the romance.
  4. Emotional Release: Writing can be therapeutic. She might have penned this letter to process her own feelings and thoughts, not necessarily to provoke a response from you.
  5. Information Update: Occasionally, the letter might be practical rather than emotional. She could be informing you about a significant life change, such as moving to a new city or starting a new relationship.

Crafting Your Response: A Scenario-Based Approach

Your response should be as thoughtful and considerate as the letter itself. Let’s explore different scenarios and how you might handle each one.

Scenario 1: The Closure Letter

Example: “Dear John, I’ve spent a lot of time thinking about us, and I’ve come to realize that I need to move on for my own well-being. I hope you understand and find happiness.”

Your Response: Acknowledge her feelings and express your own. Keep it respectful and avoid delving into past grievances. “Dear [Her Name], thank you for sharing your thoughts with me. I understand and respect your need for closure. I wish you all the best in your future endeavors. Take care.”

Scenario 2: The Apology Letter

Example: “Dear John, I want to apologize for the way things ended between us. I regret my actions and hope you can find it in your heart to forgive me.”

Your Response: If you feel comfortable, offer forgiveness. This can be a healing experience for both parties. “Dear [Her Name], thank you for your apology. I appreciate your honesty and am willing to let go of any past hurt. I hope we can both move forward positively. Best wishes.”

Scenario 3: The Rekindling Letter

Example: “Dear John, I’ve been thinking a lot about our time together and wondering if we might have a chance to start over. I miss you.”

Your Response: Consider your feelings carefully. If you’re open to the idea, suggest a meeting to discuss things further. If not, be honest but gentle. “Dear [Her Name], it’s good to hear from you. I think we should meet up and talk about this in person. How about coffee next week?”

Or, if you’re not interested: “Dear [Her Name], I appreciate your honesty. I’ve moved on, but I hope you find happiness and peace. Take care.”

Scenario 4: The Emotional Release Letter

Example: “Dear John, writing this is more for me than for you. I needed to express my feelings and put them out there.”

Your Response: Validate her feelings and acknowledge the courage it took to write the letter. “Dear [Her Name], thank you for sharing your feelings with me. I understand the importance of processing emotions and I wish you well in your journey. All the best.”

Scenario 5: The Information Update Letter

What Are Your Chances of Getting Your Ex Girlfriend Back?

Take the quiz

Example: “Dear John, I wanted to let you know that I’m moving to another city for a new job. I thought you should hear it from me.”

Your Response: Be courteous and wish her well. “Dear [Her Name], thank you for letting me know. Congratulations on the new job and the move. I hope everything goes smoothly for you. Best of luck.”

The “Never-Ever” List

When dealing with a “Dear John” letter, there are certain pitfalls you must avoid to maintain dignity and respect for both parties involved.

  1. Don’t React Impulsively: Take time to process the letter before responding. Knee-jerk reactions often lead to regret.
  2. Avoid Blame Games: This isn’t the time to rehash old arguments or point fingers. Keep the tone positive and forward-looking.
  3. Don’t Beg or Plead: Maintaining your self-respect is crucial. Begging for another chance can come off as desperate and counterproductive.
  4. No Public Drama: Resist the urge to vent on social media or involve mutual friends. Keep the matter private between the two of you.
  5. Don’t Ignore It: While it might be tempting to pretend the letter never arrived, ignoring it can leave unresolved tension. Acknowledge her effort, even if your response is brief.
  6. Avoid Over-Analyzing: It’s easy to read too much into her words. Take the letter at face value and respond accordingly.
  7. Don’t Make Rash Decisions: Whether it’s jumping into a new relationship or making a big life change, avoid making impulsive decisions based on the emotional impact of the letter.

The Art of Self-Reflection

Receiving a “Dear John” letter can be a pivotal moment for self-reflection. Use this opportunity to consider your own feelings and future.

  1. Assess Your Emotions: How does the letter make you feel? Are you relieved, saddened, or nostalgic? Understanding your emotions can help guide your next steps.
  2. Reflect on the Relationship: What did you learn from your time together? What were the strengths and weaknesses of the relationship? This introspection can provide valuable insights for your future relationships.
  3. Set Personal Goals: Whether it’s focusing on personal growth, career aspirations, or new hobbies, setting goals can help you move forward positively.
  4. Seek Support: Talking to a trusted friend or therapist can help you process your feelings and gain clarity.

The Role of No Contact After Receiving a “Dear John” Letter

Receiving a “Dear John” letter from an ex-girlfriend can stir a whirlwind of emotions, and the “No Contact” rule plays a pivotal role in navigating this challenging period. The No Contact rule entails cutting off all communication with your ex for a designated period, typically 30 to 90 days. This strategy can be profoundly beneficial for several reasons:

Emotional Healing

The immediate aftermath of receiving a “Dear John” letter is often marked by intense emotions—sadness, anger, confusion, and longing. Engaging in No Contact allows you to process these feelings without the constant reminder of your ex. It creates a space for emotional detox, helping you regain stability and clarity.

Self-Reflection and Growth

No Contact provides an opportunity for introspection. Without the distraction of your ex’s presence, you can focus on understanding the relationship’s dynamics and your role in its outcome. This period of self-reflection is crucial for personal growth, enabling you to identify patterns, recognize mistakes, and develop a stronger sense of self.

Breaking Dependency

Post-breakup, it’s easy to fall into a pattern of dependency, where your mood and actions are influenced by your ex. No Contact helps break this cycle, fostering independence. It encourages you to find solace and happiness within yourself rather than relying on external validation from your ex.

Reducing Miscommunication

In the emotionally charged period following a breakup, communication can often lead to misunderstandings, arguments, or unintended hurt. No Contact minimizes these risks, preventing further emotional damage and preserving the dignity and respect between both parties.

Re-establishing Boundaries

Boundaries are often blurred in the wake of a breakup. No Contact helps re-establish these boundaries, reinforcing the notion that both individuals need time and space to heal and move forward independently.

Potential for Reconciliation

Ironically, No Contact can also pave the way for future reconciliation. It allows both parties to miss each other, gain perspective, and possibly appreciate the relationship’s value. If reconciliation is a possibility, approaching it after a period of No Contact ensures both individuals are in a healthier emotional state to make that decision.

Final Thoughts

A “Dear John” letter can be a complex and emotional experience. By understanding the motivations behind the letter, responding thoughtfully, avoiding common pitfalls, and engaging in self-reflection, you can navigate this challenging situation with grace and maturity.

Remember, this letter is just one chapter in your life’s story. How you respond and move forward will shape the next chapters. Embrace the journey, learn from the experience, and look forward to the opportunities that await you.

In the end, life is about growth and change. Every relationship, whether it ends with a heartfelt letter or a quiet goodbye, contributes to your personal narrative. Embrace it all, and keep moving forward with confidence and optimism.




Disclosure: I am the Author and Creator of this content. My aim is to provide you with original, well structured and authoritative content about this ex recovery topic utilizing my experience and expertise. I have endeavored to produce content that is high quality, relevant, informative, accurate, and reliable. In doing so, I have used an AI tool to some extent to assist me in generating useful content for my readers. This assistance may include topic research, the development of outline structures, phraseology for titles and headings, content curation, narrative expansion, grammar usage, and optimizing readability. All of this is done for the purpose of adding value to the post that I have produced. I personally “proof” every quality post I write for accuracy, completeness, textual flow, fine-tuning purposes, inclusion of relevant media, and inclusion of helpful internal links to further assist the reader. I do not allow for any clutter that would distract from my content or confuse my readers.

Signed By Yours Truly, Chris Seiter, Founder of Ex Boyfriend & Ex Girlfriend Recovery.	

Related Articles