By Chris Seiter

Published on February 25th, 2024

One particularly perplexing scenario is when an ex-girlfriend appears to be overtly demonstrating that she’s moved on, leaving you to wonder about the authenticity of her post-breakup demeanor.

Indeed, it can be very confusing when your ex is pretending that she doesn’t care for you.  But in the back of your mind, you probably know better.  You probably realize that it is part of an act or that your ex just really has not gotten fully in touch with their true feelings.

Let’s delve into the potential reasons behind this behavior, explore some less common motivations, and outline a thoughtful plan of action to navigate this delicate situation, especially under the No Contact Rule.

What Are Your Chances of Getting Your Ex Girlfriend Back?

Take the quiz

Top 8 Reasons Why Your Ex Might Pretend to Be Over You

  1. Self-Preservation: Post-breakup, the instinct to protect one’s emotional well-being is strong. Your ex might project an image of being over you as a defense mechanism to safeguard her heart from further pain.
  2. Seeking Closure: Sometimes, the act of pretending to be over a relationship is a step towards achieving personal closure. This outward declaration can be more for her benefit, helping her convince herself that she’s ready to move on.
  3. Ego Boost: The end of a relationship can leave one’s self-esteem bruised. By appearing unaffected, your ex might be trying to boost her ego, portraying herself as resilient and in control.
  4. Provoking Jealousy or Reaction: This age-old tactic is often employed to gauge an ex-partner’s feelings. She might be seeking validation of your feelings for her or attempting to reignite a spark by inciting jealousy.
  5. Peer Pressure: Societal and peer expectations can pressure individuals to bounce back quickly after a breakup. Your ex might be succumbing to this pressure, pretending to be over you to align with perceived social norms.
  6. New Beginnings: She might view the pretense of moving on as a necessary step towards new beginnings, using it as a way to mentally and emotionally free herself from the past.
  7. Avoiding Conflict: If the breakup was tumultuous, your ex might pretend to be over you to avoid further conflict or uncomfortable discussions about the relationship’s demise.
  8. Protecting Feelings: She might still have feelings for you and is using this facade as a way to protect herself from rejection or the pain of seeing you move on.

4 Unusual Reasons Your Ex Might Pretend to Be Over You

  1. Social Media Influence: In the era of curated online personas, your ex might feel compelled to appear over you on social media platforms to maintain a certain image or to cater to her online audience’s expectations.
  2. Influenced by Dating Advice: She might be adhering to specific dating advice or strategies that advocate for a “strong, moved-on” appearance as a means to either win you back or to boost her dating prospects.
  3. Subconscious Mimicry: Sometimes, people subconsciously mimic the behaviors and coping mechanisms of those around them. If her friends or influencers she admires advocate for a “tough, over-it” post-breakup attitude, she might adopt this stance unknowingly.
  4. Experimental Phase: Post-breakup can be a time of self-discovery and experimentation. Pretending to be over you might be her way of experimenting with new identities or personas as she navigates her single life.

What Should You Do If Your Ex Is Pretending To Be Over You: A 7-Step Plan

When faced with an ex who seems to be pretending to be over you, especially if you’re adhering to the No Contact Rule, navigating your response requires a blend of introspection, respect for her journey, and a focus on personal growth.

  1. Reflect on Your Feelings: Assess why her behavior impacts you. Are you hoping for reconciliation, or are you seeking closure? Your feelings will guide your response.
  2. Respect the No Contact Rule: If you’ve committed to no contact, respect this boundary. It’s in place for healing and provides both parties with the space needed to reflect and grow.
  3. Focus on Personal Growth: Use this period to invest in yourself. Explore new hobbies, reconnect with friends, and work on personal goals. Growth and self-improvement can provide clarity and strength, regardless of the future of your past relationship.
  4. Avoid Stalking Your Ex: Constantly keeping tabs on her through social media can skew your perception and hinder your healing. Focus on your path and well-being instead.
  5. Seek Support From a Coach:  We offer coaching services and such a support system can offer perspective and comfort as you navigate this confusing time.
  6. Consider Your Ex’s Perspective: Try to understand the possible reasons behind her actions without judgment. Acknowledging that she’s also navigating her post-breakup journey can foster empathy and acceptance.
  7. Embrace Acceptance and Let Go If Necessary: Ultimately, her actions and feelings are beyond your control. Embracing acceptance and focusing on moving forward can liberate you from the cycle of speculation and enable you to embrace new opportunities for happiness and fulfillment.

What Not to Do If Your Former Lover is Pretending About Their True Feelings?

  1. Don’t Confront Your Ex: Confronting her about her behavior, especially if adhering to the No Contact Rule, can lead to unnecessary drama and emotional turmoil for both parties.
  2. Avoid Retaliation: Trying to “one-up” her by pretending to be over her or flaunting a new relationship can escalate tensions and impede personal growth.
  3. Don’t Ruminate: Obsessing over her actions and motives can trap you in a cycle of negativity and prevent you from moving forward.
  4. Resist the Urge to Reconnect Prematurely: If you’re considering breaking the No Contact Rule to address her behavior, pause and reflect. Ensure any decision to reconnect is grounded in a desire for healthy closure or reconciliation, not a knee-jerk reaction to her actions.
  5. Don’t Ignore Your Healing: Neglecting your emotional well-being by fixating on her behavior can prolong the healing process. Prioritize self-care and activities that nurture your spirit and well-being.

The Expert’s Corner – Insights From Chris Seiter

When it seems like your ex is pretending to be through with you, you gotta know what to do. Here are seven key FAQs to help guide you through the uncertainty.

1. Why would my ex-girlfriend pretend to be over me?

Your ex-girlfriend might pretend to be over you for various reasons, including protecting her emotional well-being, seeking closure, trying to boost her self-esteem, or attempting to provoke a reaction from you. She might also be influenced by her social circle, trying to adhere to perceived societal norms about moving on, or using this facade as a way to navigate her healing process.

2. How can I tell if she’s genuinely moved on or just pretending?

Discerning genuine emotional detachment from pretense can be challenging. Signs she might be pretending include overemphasizing her happiness on social media, making a point to show off her “moved-on” status in mutual social settings, or her actions and words not aligning (e.g., saying she’s over you but frequently bringing up memories or issues from your relationship). Remember, focusing too much on these signs can impede your healing process.

3. Should I confront my ex about her behavior?

Confronting your ex about whether she’s pretending to be over you is generally not advisable. This could lead to unnecessary conflict and emotional turmoil. It’s important to focus on your healing and respect her journey, regardless of its authenticity.

4. What does it mean for me if my ex is pretending to be over me?

If your ex is pretending to be over you, it could indicate unresolved feelings on her part. However, it’s crucial to focus on what this means for you in terms of your emotional closure and healing. Whether she’s pretending or not, your priority should be navigating your feelings and moving forward.

5. How should I react to my ex’s behavior in social settings?

In social settings, the best approach is to maintain composure and act cordially. You don’t need to engage extensively with her or the facade she might be putting up. Focus on enjoying your time and the company of others, reinforcing your independence and emotional strength.

6. Is there a chance my ex wants me to reach out if she’s pretending to be over me?

While there’s a possibility that her behavior is a bid for your attention, it’s a risky assumption to act on. Reaching out could lead to further confusion or hurt if she’s genuinely trying to move on. If you’re considering reconnecting, ensure it’s for reasons aligned with mutual respect and closure, not just a reaction to her current behavior.

7. How can I move on if I’m constantly wondering about her true feelings?

Moving on requires shifting the focus from her actions and feelings to your own path of healing and growth. Engage in activities that enrich your life, seek support from friends and loved ones, and possibly explore your feelings with a therapist. Embracing hobbies, setting new goals, and allowing yourself to grieve and heal can gradually reduce the fixation on her behaviors and lead you toward emotional independence.




Disclosure: I am the Author and Creator of this content. My aim is to provide you with original, well structured and authoritative content about this ex recovery topic utilizing my experience and expertise. I have endeavored to produce content that is high quality, relevant, informative, accurate, and reliable. In doing so, I have used an AI tool to some extent to assist me in generating useful content for my readers. This assistance may include topic research, the development of outline structures, phraseology for titles and headings, content curation, narrative expansion, grammar usage, and optimizing readability. All of this is done for the purpose of adding value to the post that I have produced. I personally “proof” every quality post I write for accuracy, completeness, textual flow, fine-tuning purposes, inclusion of relevant media, and inclusion of helpful internal links to further assist the reader. I do not allow for any clutter that would distract from my content or confuse my readers.

Signed By Yours Truly, Chris Seiter, Founder of Ex Boyfriend & Ex Girlfriend Recovery.	

Related Articles